Should I overpay my mortgage or save?
If you have money to spare, you can pay down your mortgage or keep it in savings. This guide compares the two with the 2026/27 tax rules, works through examples and sets out what else to weigh up.
By Oliver Cran · Last updated:
This is general information, not financial advice. Which suits you depends on your own circumstances.
The basic comparison
Every pound you overpay stops being charged interest at your mortgage rate. So overpaying works like a savings account that pays your mortgage rate. You know the return for as long as your rate stays the same, and because it is interest you no longer pay, there is no tax on it. Savings earn their own rate, and the interest may be taxed. The comparison is your mortgage rate against your savings rate after any tax.
Tax on savings interest in 2026/27
Most people can earn some interest tax-free. Your Personal Savings Allowance depends on your income tax band:
- basic rate: £1,000 of interest a year
- higher rate: £500
- additional rate: £0
Interest above the allowance is taxed at your usual rate: 20%, 40% or 45%, the same across the UK. If your other income is under £17,570, the starting rate for savings can also let you earn up to £5,000 of interest tax-free. Interest on cash in an ISA is not taxed, and you can put up to £20,000 into ISAs in 2026/27.
Savings tax from 6 April 2027
From 6 April 2027, the tax rates on savings interest go up by 4 percentage points in every band, to 24%, 44% and 49%. The rise was announced in two equal steps, at Budget 2025 and Budget 2026. The Personal Savings Allowance and the £5,000 starting rate for savings stay the same, and interest in a cash ISA is still not taxed.
Comparing a savings rate after tax with your mortgage rate
For interest above your allowance, take your tax rate off the savings rate. A 4% account leaves 3.2% for a basic rate taxpayer, 2.4% for higher rate and 2.2% for additional rate. Interest inside your allowance, or in a cash ISA, keeps the full 4%.
Turned round, to match a 4.5% mortgage with interest above your allowance, a savings account would need to pay 5.63% before tax for a basic rate taxpayer, 7.5% for higher rate and 8.18% for additional rate.
From 6 April 2027, with the higher savings tax rates, a 4% account leaves 3.04% for a basic rate taxpayer, 2.24% for higher rate and 2.04% for additional rate. To match a 4.5% mortgage it would need to pay 5.92%, 8.04% and 8.82% before tax.
Worked examples
Each uses £20,000 and a £200,000 repayment mortgage with 25 years left. The overpayment figures come from our mortgage overpayment calculator, which charges interest monthly, so it saves a little more than the headline rate. The savings figures are for one year at 4%, with no other savings interest. £20,000 is 10% of the balance, the most many lenders allow in a year without a charge.
A basic rate taxpayer, 4.5% mortgage, 4% savings
Overpaying saves £919 of interest in the first year. Saving earns £800, all inside the £1,000 allowance, so there is no tax. If other savings already use up the allowance, the tax is £160 and you keep £640. Left in the mortgage for the rest of the term, the overpayment saves £35,968 in interest and ends the mortgage 4 years and 2 months early.
A higher rate taxpayer, same rates
Overpaying still saves £919 in the first year. Saving earns £800, but the allowance is £500, so £300 is taxed at 40%: £120. You keep £680. In a cash ISA you would keep all £800.
A fixed rate that ends in a year
On a 2% fixed rate, overpaying £20,000 saves £404 of interest over that year. Saving it at 4% earns £800 after tax for a basic rate taxpayer, or £680 for higher rate. When the fixed rate ends, you can still overpay, and on a lender's standard variable rate there is usually no limit. What overpaying saves after that depends on the rate you move to, which is not known yet.
The same examples from 6 April 2027
The examples above use the 2026/27 rates. With the savings tax rates from 6 April 2027, and the same savings and mortgage rates:
- a basic rate taxpayer whose interest stays inside the allowance still keeps all £800. If other savings use up the allowance, the tax is £192 and you keep £608
- a higher rate taxpayer pays 44% on the £300 over the allowance, which is £132, and keeps £668
- the interest overpaying saves does not change, because it is not taxed: still £919 in the first year on a 4.5% mortgage
What else changes the answer
- An emergency fund. MoneyHelper suggests keeping enough to live on for at least three months before paying your mortgage off early.
- Getting the money back. Overpayments usually cannot be withdrawn unless you have a flexible or offset mortgage. Money in an easy-access savings account can.
- Early repayment charges. Many lenders let you overpay up to 10% a year without a fee while you are on a fixed rate, and you could be charged for going over. The calculator checks your overpayments against your limit.
- Other debts. Credit cards and loans usually charge more interest than a mortgage, and MoneyHelper says to pay them off before reducing your mortgage.
- The end of your fixed rate. Unless you take a new deal, you move to the lender's standard variable rate, which is often higher. A higher rate means each pound overpaid saves more.
- Pensions. Contributions get tax relief, and workplace pensions get money from your employer too, so MoneyHelper says you might get more for your money in a pension than you would save in mortgage interest. The pay rise calculator shows how pension tax relief changes your take-home pay.
- A home in the future. A Lifetime ISA adds a 25% bonus for a first home or for later life, but has a charge for taking money out for anything else.
Common questions
Is overpaying the same as saving at my mortgage rate?
Close to it. Each pound overpaid saves interest at your mortgage rate, with no tax, for as long as that rate lasts. Unlike savings, you usually cannot take it back out.
Do I pay tax on interest in a cash ISA?
No. Interest on cash in an ISA is not taxed. The ISA allowance calculator shows how much of your 2026/27 allowance is left.
What if my savings rate after tax is higher than my mortgage rate?
Then saving earns more than overpaying would save, while the rates stay as they are, and you can still get at the money. Rates can change, on savings and on mortgages.
Where this comes from
From gov.uk: tax on savings interest, how ISAs work, pension tax relief, the Budget 2025 document and the Budget 2026 rates and allowances. From MoneyHelper: should you pay off your mortgage early? and understanding mortgages and interest rates.